Sost Today

Top Menu

  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Contributors
  • Usage and Comments

Main Menu

  • Home
  • Gilgit Baltistan
  • Chitral
  • Politics
  • Opinion
  • Education
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Contributors
  • Usage and Comments

logo

Header Banner

Sost Today

  • Home
  • Gilgit Baltistan
    • Khunjerav National Park team including Mehmood Ghaznavi Conservator, Assistant Commissioner Hunza Zulqarnain, ...

      June 13, 2020
      0
    • Illegal goods disposed of at NLC-SRDP sost dryport.

      December 4, 2019
      0
    • Karakuram Highway reopened one way for traffic

      July 29, 2019
      0
    • Pakistan’s mountain princess sets new world record

      July 29, 2019
      0
    • Government intends to create Ministry of Development and Special Initiatives

      July 23, 2019
      0
    • Baba Ghundi festival-2019 — an auspicious affair to attract religious tourism

      July 22, 2019
      0
    • A long pending issue of Hussaini and Passu.

      July 8, 2019
      0
    • Shisper Glacier hassanabad Hunza has completely discharged

      June 27, 2019
      0
    • Good News for people of Gilgit-Baltistan.

      June 27, 2019
      0
  • Chitral
    • TMA Chitral distributing Free Mask, Gloves and sanitizer among the people to ...

      April 10, 2020
      0
    • Thousands of tourists entered in kalash valley, mostly complained of deteriorated condition ...

      June 11, 2019
      0
    • Govternment urged to save school from flash floods at upper Chitral.

      May 27, 2019
      0
    • kalash elder passes away; three day funeral celebration begins

      May 27, 2019
      0
    • Foreign tourists throng Chitral after relaxation of NOC condition

      May 22, 2019
      0
    • Climate woes: Water shortage causes displacement in snow-caped Chitral

      December 18, 2018
      0
    • Upper Chitral notified as district

      November 27, 2018
      0
    • DPO Chitral inaugurates 3 Day Science Technology and Arts Competition Organized by ...

      November 19, 2018
      0
    • AKHSS Chitral Participates in Countrywide Plantation Drive

      September 6, 2018
      0
  • Politics
    • Police Present Nine Accused Including MLA Before ATC

      November 9, 2018
      0
    • Govt Taking Steps For Socio-economic Development Of GB: Parliamentary Sec

      November 9, 2018
      0
    • President to address joint session today

      September 17, 2018
      0
    • Sabir Hussain likely to be new GB governor

      August 7, 2018
      0
    • Ex-minister Saira Tarar’s two cousins arrested

      July 26, 2018
      0
    • Hajat Muhammad from Jamalabad Gojal Hunza has announced to contest in the ...

      May 23, 2018
      0
    • People from different segments of life in Gilgit Baltistan termed the federal ...

      April 28, 2018
      0
    • Gilgit-Baltistan government refuses parole to prisoner for Nikah: report

      April 18, 2018
      0
    • GB chapter of PML-N turns against party leadership

      February 26, 2018
      0
  • Opinion
    • Terrorism and Tourism

      August 14, 2018
      0
    • Will Imran change the status-quo in Gilgit-Baltistan

      August 12, 2018
      0
    • Gilgit-Baltistan on target | THE EXPRESS TRIBUNE

      August 12, 2018
      0
    • CPEC: A Boon for Gilgit-Baltistan

      August 6, 2018
      0
    • Of poached eggs and maple syrup

      July 29, 2018
      0
    • CPEC: the new economic corridor

      July 23, 2018
      0
    • Economic geology of CPEC: Part - II

      May 6, 2018
      0
    • Economic geology of CPEC

      May 5, 2018
      0
    • A symbol of political sanity

      February 21, 2018
      0
  • Education
    • ML Learning is an educational Institution specialized in providing Distance-based Training & ...

      June 17, 2019
      0
    • Education background in Gilgit-Baltistan.

      May 22, 2019
      0
    • Naeem Ullah Baig from Gilgit-Baltistan received Gold Medal in MA Socio-Culture Anthropology ...

      May 16, 2019
      0
    • GISAK organizes a session on "CPEC" and "Impacts of Social Media"

      March 10, 2019
      0
    • Karakoram International University Announced Various Position:

      January 13, 2019
      0
    • Digital Security Training Workshop held at Karakoram Univarisity

      September 6, 2018
      0
    • Upskilling students: SECP, Karakorum University sign deal

      August 17, 2018
      0
    • GB DWP approves establishment of 70 girls schools in Diamer

      August 11, 2018
      0
    • Two girls’ schools torched in Pishin Balochistan

      August 8, 2018
      0
  • Khunjerav National Park team including Mehmood Ghaznavi Conservator, Assistant Commissioner Hunza Zulqarnain, Serctary forest Gilgit Baltistan Shahid Zaman has distributed Rs.11529625/- to the community of Khunjerav villagers organization.

  • TMA Chitral distributing Free Mask, Gloves and sanitizer among the people to protect from Corona virus.

  • Illegal goods disposed of at NLC-SRDP sost dryport.

  • Karakuram Highway reopened one way for traffic

  • Pakistan’s mountain princess sets new world record

Gilgit BaltistanOpinion
Home›Gilgit Baltistan›Gilgit case and intolerance

Gilgit case and intolerance

By Sost Today English
December 4, 2014
322
0
Share:

By: I.A. Rehman

I.A. Rehman

I.A. Rehman

THE government must address the issues raised by the Gilgit anti-terrorism court’s curious verdict against media persons, for much more is at stake than the legal rights of the defendants.

The court’s decision whereby the Jang group’s editor-in-chief, an anchor at Geo TV and two guests at a talk show have each been sentenced in absentia to 26 years’ imprisonment and a fine of Rs1.3 million, has caused anger and dismay in media circles at home and abroad.

The heads of the Council of Pakistan Newspaper Editors and the All-Pakistan Newspapers Society have categorically declared that “the unlawful conviction of media persons in Gilgit-Baltistan constitutes a major threat to the existence of a free press throughout the country”. Amnesty International has said the decision will have a “chilling effect on freedom of expression in Pakistan”. A similar concern has been expressed by Freedom Network.

That the case formed part of a well-orchestrated campaign to muzzle the voice of the media is evident from record. No less than 75 cases were registered against the defendants in different parts of the country on the charge of showing disrespect to the Ahle Bayt. This happened during a period when the Jang group was being punished in a variety of ways for stirring up a hornet’s nest. The Geo channel was duly punished by Pemra, the authority competent to deal with affairs of this nature, and the matter should have ended there. That it didn’t meant that vendetta was the objective of the campaign and not justice.

The Gilgit court has confirmed that the threat to media freedom — and the people’s right to freedom of expression — has assumed menacing proportions. Obviously, the entire body of human rights is under pressure. The authorities and human rights activists both have a clear duty to ensure that the challenge to media freedom is effectively thwarted.


The Gilgit court has confirmed that the threat to media freedom has assumed menacing proportions.


Besides, the case indicates a gross abuse of the legal process. The accusation fell under Section 298-A of the Penal Code, punishable with three years’ imprisonment. The provision does not attract the label of blasphemy. Yet great noise was made that the accused had committed blasphemy. Once that was done the defendants lost their right to justice, even to a fair trial. The administration, subordinate courts, lawyers and journalists all have to be on guard against this kind of incitement to violence, otherwise the country will go on witnessing Kot Radha Kishan-type outrages.

It is doubtful that this case should have gone to the anti-terrorism court at all and whether the Gilgit court was right in invoking the sections of the Anti-Terrorism Act that it did to hand down stiff penalties. Complaints of inappropriate application of the anti-terrorism law have been growing over the years, especially following its application to trade union workers and civil rights activists, and it is time the Justice and Law Commission looked for ways to stop its misuse.

Several legal experts, including the president of the Supreme Court Bar, have criticised the conviction of the defendants on charges that had been dismissed by two anti-terrorism courts in Karachi and by another anti-terrorism court in Balochistan. Who will secure the victims’ right to protection under the principle that no one can be prosecuted more than once for a single offence?

The issue of the Gilgit court’s competence to try the media persons has been raised by all the critics and the flaw in the order under which the Gilgit courts are functioning cannot be left unattended. The very basis of the legal order in the sensitive Gilgit-Baltistan region is under attack. The urgency of swift remedial action is obvious.

From whatever angle one looks at the Gilgit court affair — threat to media freedom, abuse of law, the inflammable nature of the PPC provisions on offences relating to religion — the issue boils down to the rise of intolerance as the determinant of both individual and group behaviour. Nobody can advance ideas the custodians of power or faith or morality have arbitrarily put beyond the pale of tolerance, or even discourse. Herein lies the root cause of Pakistan’s troubles.

Those in authority do sometimes, when they are not engaged in saving their chairs, recognise intolerance as the biggest threat to Pakistan but they seem to have no clue as to what they should do about it. And they are not ready to accept the counsel offered from any quarter.

For instance, the Supreme Court in its widely acclaimed judgment of June 19 this year had advised the government to take a few specific steps. The court had taken up the cases of attacks on the Peshawar church and other non-Muslim prayer houses, and quite significantly the first three of the court’s seven recommendations called for a well-defined, long-term drive against intolerance.

First, the court asked the government to constitute a task force for developing a strategy for promoting religious tolerance.

Secondly, it called for reform of school/college curricula so as to ensure compliance with the UN call to protect the child from any belief-based discrimination and ensure his upbringing in a spirit of understanding, tolerance, friendship among peoples, peace and universal brotherhood.

And, thirdly, the court called upon the federal government to take steps to discourage hate speech in the media and bring the delinquents to justice.

Apart from its duty to honour the Supreme Court advice the government should have the good sense to realise the need to defuse the time bomb it has been foolishly sitting upon for so long.

Tailpiece: Asked about Pakistan’s future, Mortimer Wheeler, who added 5,000 years to this country’s history, reproduced a news item about a student pulling out his dagger when hauled up for cheating in a Matric examination. What would he, or anyone else, have said on reading of cheating by Pakistan’s PhD and M.Phil candidates? Progress?

Published in Dawn December 4th , 2014

Related

Tagsanit-terrorismatcBaltistanfreedomgeoGilgithuman rightsJang groupmPakistanshakil-ur-rehanveena malik
Previous Article

GBSM for cerebrating liberation from Pakistan

Next Article

Chitral; BISP Assistant Director Didar Ahmad Parvez ...

0
Shares
  • 0
  • +
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0

Sost Today English

Sost Today is a platform for the Participatory Journalists of Gilgit-Baltistan and Chitral, where we share a very diverse information including News, articles, events, photo and video in different categories like social, political, economical, cultural, socioeconomic, sports, health, education, travel and so on. Sost Today is non-profit blog founded in 2013 and operates with volunteer editors and the reporters are not paid for their articles. Updated continuously by citizens like you. You are all welcomed to be a part of Sost Today. Send your detail at [email protected]

Related articles More from author

  • Opinion

    Economic geology of CPEC

    May 5, 2018
    By Sost Today English
  • EconomicsGilgit Baltistan

    Govt focusing to establish industrial zones in Gilgit Baltistan: Barjees

    February 13, 2014
    By Sost Today English
  • CultureGilgit Baltistan

    Balti language script course starts in Karachi.

    March 18, 2014
    By Sost Today English
  • Economics

    DIAMIR-BHASHA DAM CONSTRUCTION TO START IN NEXT YEAR

    December 28, 2015
    By Sost Today English
  • Tour and travelTravelogue

    Travel: A trip along the China-Pakistan border

    January 18, 2014
    By Sost Today English
  • Gilgit BaltistanNational

    WAPDA to construct 3 model villages for the affectees of Diamar Basha Dam

    March 15, 2014
    By Sost Today English

Leave a reply Cancel reply

You may interested

  • Gilgit BaltistanTour and travel

    US envoy hails Pakistani mountaineer siblings Samina Baig and Mirza Ali

  • Opinion

    ZIONISM’S PLANTED TREE BECAME STRONG

  • EducationGilgit Baltistan

    [Profile] A Teacher, Mentor and a committed Educationist

  • Uncategorized

    Population load of targeted parasites and bacteria in pit latrine at Oshkhandas Valley, Gilgit-Baltistan, Pakistan

Find us on Facebook

Timeline

  • June 13, 2020

    Khunjerav National Park team including Mehmood Ghaznavi Conservator, Assistant Commissioner Hunza Zulqarnain, Serctary forest Gilgit Baltistan Shahid Zaman has distributed Rs.11529625/- to the community of Khunjerav villagers organization.

  • April 10, 2020

    TMA Chitral distributing Free Mask, Gloves and sanitizer among the people to protect from Corona virus.

  • December 4, 2019

    Illegal goods disposed of at NLC-SRDP sost dryport.

  • July 29, 2019

    Karakuram Highway reopened one way for traffic

  • July 29, 2019

    Pakistan’s mountain princess sets new world record

Recent Posts

  • Khunjerav National Park team including Mehmood Ghaznavi Conservator, Assistant Commissioner Hunza Zulqarnain, Serctary forest Gilgit Baltistan Shahid Zaman has distributed Rs.11529625/- to the community of Khunjerav villagers organization.
  • TMA Chitral distributing Free Mask, Gloves and sanitizer among the people to protect from Corona virus.
  • Illegal goods disposed of at NLC-SRDP sost dryport.
  • Karakuram Highway reopened one way for traffic
  • Pakistan’s mountain princess sets new world record

Latest Tweets

    Please install plugin name "oAuth Twitter Feed for Developers

Connect Us

  • 1809
    Followers
  • Likes
  • 84
    Followers
logo
  • Pakistan
  • (0092)
  • [email protected]

Follow us

  • Recent

  • Popular

  • Comments

  • Khunjerav National Park team including Mehmood Ghaznavi Conservator, Assistant Commissioner Hunza Zulqarnain, Serctary forest Gilgit ...

    By Sost Today English
    June 13, 2020
  • TMA Chitral distributing Free Mask, Gloves and sanitizer among the people to protect from Corona ...

    By Sost Today English
    April 10, 2020
  • Illegal goods disposed of at NLC-SRDP sost dryport.

    By Sost Today English
    December 4, 2019
  • Karakuram Highway reopened one way for traffic

    By Sost Today English
    July 29, 2019
  • Hussain Karim Jafaq of Altit Hunza represented DDI in Green Campus initiative seminar

    By Sost Today English
    November 28, 2013
  • Najeeb Ullah Baig of Gilgit Baltistan raised the flag of Pakistan at an international sports ...

    By Sost Today English
    October 11, 2013
  • Gurg Ali from Sost Gojal passed away

    By Sost Today English
    December 3, 2013
  • Cabinet of Silk Route Dry Port Trust Sost elected today

    By Sost Today English
    August 18, 2013
  • Bharoo bheel
    on
    January 19, 2019

    Development through empowerment: the AKDN way- Interview with Hafiz Sherali Chairman AKPBS,Pakistan

    خدمت میں جناب ...
  • Bharoo bheel
    on
    January 13, 2019

    Development through empowerment: the AKDN way- Interview with Hafiz Sherali Chairman AKPBS,Pakistan

    To ...
  • Dr Zafirah Salman from Gircha Gojal Hunza Gilgit-Baltistan has passed her Fellowship in Critical Care Pulmonology ...
    on
    December 19, 2018

    Drug addiction becoming a major social evil in Chitral

    […] Drug addiction becoming ...
  • faqeer muhammad
    on
    December 13, 2013

    The procedure of applying for Prime Minister’s Youth Business Loan

    can blood relative be ...

Photostream

    • سوست ٹوڈے اردو
    • Contact Us
    © Copyright SOST TODAY. All rights reserved.